Skip to Main Content
University of Phoenix logo
University Library

Verify Citations from Generative AI

What is the difference between generative AI tools and library databases?

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools, like ChatGPT or Microsoft Copilot, are large language models (LLMs) meant to predict text. They are trained on a large dataset of internet sources and analyze text to predict what word will likely come next.

Library databases are collections of published resources (academic journals, newspapers, reports, magazines, eBooks, etc.)  stored and indexed for searching.

The two are very different systems designed to do different things. GenAI, by its nature, was not designed to research. So when you ask a GenAI tool to do so, it often creates fake citations called hallucinations because it has been programmed to respond rather than be accurate.

GenAI and Reference Credibility

GenAI can be an effective tool for assisting with research preparation (generating keywords, formatting citations, etc.) and writing. It should not be used as a substitute for a research database or tool.

  • Hallucinated (fake) citations. Just because GenAI provides a citation for an article does not mean that the article exists. GenAI is answering the prompt with what it thinks are examples of sources relevant to your research topic.
  • Real and fake citations. Some references provided by GenAI may exist because they were included in the training data, but no distinction is made between actual and made-up citations in a list it generates.
  • Sorta real citations. GenAI may provide a citation for an article that exists in a journal, but it does not mean that the journal actually published that article. You will need to verify if the entire citation is correct (author, article title, date, journal name), as GenAI has been known to combine citation elements from multiple sources.
  • Real citations with misplaced content. GenAI may combine the body of an article with an entirely different citation. You should critically examine the material to ensure that the content you want to reference has been taken from this source.

Strategies to Verify GenAI Citations

The following strategies can be used to verify whether a citation generated by a GenAI tool is legitimate. You may need to use a combination of the strategies below to decide.

We recommend starting your search for a citation in the order provided below. If the citation is correct and available in the library, you can move on to critically evaluating the resource to ensure it supports the content you are creating.

  1. Search by article or journal title in the library search box. The library search box searches most materials available in the library databases (about 80% of the library collection), making it a great place to start your search.
    1. Quotations: Use quotation marks around the titles to make your search more accurate (for example, "Knowing but Not Enacting Leadership").
    2. Advanced search: Use the Advanced search link to designate the search for either the Title or Journal Title/Source.
    3. Keywords: If your exact title does not retrieve an article, try using a few keywords from the title (for example, enter technology AND students AND education for Education technology: Does education technology help students learn?).
  2. Search by article title in Google Scholar. Google's collection of indexed articles is more expansive than the library holdings. Search for the article title using quotation marks and review the results to see if there is a match.
    1. Access Google Scholar from our library (you can also use the Research Databases icon to get the link). Using the library link will provide you with a link to the article if it is in our library.
  3. Search by journal title on the internet (i.e., Google). Most current journals can be found on the internet.

If you've reached the last step and still have not found the source, your citation is likely a hallucination and not real.

Like this guide or have feedback on it? Let us know!

Just for Fun

Think you're a GenAI citations expert? Take our verifying citations quiz and find out!

Need more help?